Creme de Menthe Oreo Cake Pops

Oreo Cake Pops   I made cake pops! Successfully. My first attempt to make them was for my oldest child's, Linus, birthday party. He wanted cake pops REALLY badly. So I was like, "Ya, sure, why not?" Well, I'll tell you why not. They are not exactly as easy as people like to make them sound. You have to figure out your technique. Obviously I am still working on mine. But I'm pretty happy with the results. When I made them for Linus' birthday things did not go so well. Making the cake balls themselves is pretty easy, so I thought I was well on my way to having perfectly beautiful cake pops. Then I started trying to dip them. Oh mother. That is when things changed and I started throwing things. A little. Yes, I am red-headed, Scotch and I have a temper. However I am also quite stubborn and really didn't jive with the thought that I had been bettered by cake pops. So after my husband laughed at me and I announced I had given up, made some cupcakes instead and then went to bed.  I started thinking. And I came up with a plan. So it turns out that it really just doesn't work to dip cake pops. They fall off the stick and crumble and bla....... Turns out you have to hold the pop sideways and spoon the coating over it until it is fully covered, let the excess drip off and start to harden and then stick it in the freezer or fridge. At least that is what I came up with. I would probably be better off watching some youtube videos but I keep using up all our bandwidth (yes, we have limited bandwidth thanks to living out in the boonies and only having access to satellite internet - which totally stinks, the internet I mean. I love living here.) so I have been trying not to watch videos so much...except my workout ones. Those are a necessary part of life. Especially when I have been making cake pops and the girl scout cookies I ordered came in yesterday. Oh yes. Girl scout cookies. I'm in big trouble. Ok so these cake pops. I decided I it would be a good idea to make them out of Oreos. Mostly because I had no eggs to make cake and no cake mix. But I DID have a box of Oreos. We don't let our kids watch tv or eat dessert during the week. However, after they go to bed it is not unusual for the hubby and I to pop in a movie and have a bowl of ice cream and lately we have been on a kick of eating vanilla ice cream with crushed Oreos all over it. Thus, we had Oreos.   Don't tell him I used his Oreos for these....  
Creme de Menthe Oreo Cake Pops
Prep time
Total time
Recipe By:
Recipe type: Dessert
Serves: makes about 24 cake pops
  • 1 package Oreo cookies
  • 1 cup (give or take) buttercream frosting
  • 2-3 tablespoons Creme de Menthe coffee syrup (I used DaVinci brand)
  • 24 cake pop sticks
  • 16oz white chocolate
  • Sprinkles (optional)
Preparation Instructions
  1. Place all the cookies in a food processor and pulse until they are fine crumbs.
  2. Pour them into the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with a paddle attachment. Add about ¾ cup of the buttercream and beat on medium high until it starts to come together to make a crumbly dough. If it does not come together, add more buttercream until it just starts to bind.
  3. Pour in the creme de menthe and beat until combined.
  4. Next get a scoop, at least a tablespoon sized - mine is about 2 tablespoons and scoop the balls onto a cookie sheet like with parchment or a silpat.
  5. Once you have them all scooped out, roll them into neat, round little balls and place them back on the tray.
  6. Once they are all rolled, place a cake pop stick into each one and place the tray in the freezer to harden.
  7. While they are hardening, melt your chocolate.
  8. Once the chocolate is melted and your pops are hard enough, start coating with chocolate. To do this, take a spoon and scoop the chocolate over the cake pop and let the excess drip off, then rotate and coat the other side. Once all the excess is dripped off, sprinkle them if you desire and place them back in the freezer to harden completely.
  9. Repeat with remaining cake pops.
  10. Once they have hardened you are ready to enjoy them!


  1. says

    Ha, you are so right! Cake pops are deceptively hard. Even when the dipping technique works, there’s also the matter of the coating cracking, or with oil leaking out from the cake pop (this usually happens to me with cream cheese frosting, for some reason.) I think someone needs to write a blog post “When Cake Pops Go Bad.” At least you ended up with some awesome pops!

  2. says

    Here are a couple of cake pop crafting tips: After rolling the cake & frosting mixture into balls, refrigerate for about 20 minutes (don’t get the too cold). Dip the end of the pop stick in melted coating or chocolate and then insert into the cake ball (this helps adhere the ball to the stick). If you are using candy wafers make sure they are fresh and do not overheat. Old wafers and overheating will cause the coating to thicken and make it difficult to dip.
    You can read my written instructions on the LorAnn website – hope this helps for next time!

    • says

      What an excellent idea! Thank you so much Sandy. I did chill mine before dipping but dipping the sticks sounds like a perfect solution to the balls falling off the sticks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: